Re: LDAP Verify Credentials operation

Ando and I have been discussing off-list the need for this op's request and response to carry additional fields. The discussion started with a separate error code to distinguish errors which might be communicated back to authenticating entity (as opposed to the LDAP client submitting the VC request). My current proposal is: /* * LDAP Verify Credentials operation * * The request is an extended request with OID 1.3.6.1.4.1.4203.666.6.5 with value of * the BER encoding of: * * VCRequest ::= SEQUENCE { * cookie [0] OCTET STRING OPTIONAL, * name LDAPDN, * authentication AuthenticationChoice * controls [3] Controls OPTIONAL * } * * where LDAPDN, AuthenticationChoice, and Controls are as defined in RFC 4511. * * The response is an extended response with no OID and a value of the BER encoding of * * VCResponse ::= SEQUENCE { * resultCode ResultCode, * diagnosticMessage LDAPString, * cookie [0] OCTET STRING OPTIONAL, * serverSaslCreds [1] OCTET STRING OPTIONAL * authzid [2] OCTET STRING OPTIONAL * controls [3] Controls OPTIONAL * } * * where ResultCode is the result code enumeration from RFC 4511, and LDAPString and Controls are as * defined in RFC 4511. */ The use of controls here is to allow both the request/return of password policy information to the authenticating entity (as opposed those used on the extended operation itself to request/return password policy information about the LDAP client submitting the VC request). Comments?