On Mon, 2008-07-07 at 11:30 -0300, Miguel Jinez wrote:

    Hi.
    I need help to fix a problem.
    I am running openLdap 2.4

Can you provide the exact version number?

    I have configurated 2 multimaster servers, which works fine,
    but I was thinking what happen if one of them die? When that
    master is restarted read the "logold" parameter in the other
    master and synchronize the changes, problem solved.
    But what happen if one master dies, meanwhile the other master
    performs changes in the Ldap tree (add, modify, delete) and
    that master dies too?

You would have no working master?

I assume you mean if changes are made on both sides while replication is not occurring. Except for conflicting changes (where the most recent change will win), all the changes should converge on all servers.

    I have test it and the deletes that I made in the second
    master are not synchronized on the first one,

I think there were some bugs fixed between 2.4.8 and 2.4.10 regarding replication of deletions. If you aren't running 2.4.10, you should upgrade and test again. If you still have problems, you should file an ITS.

     and I don t know how I can synchronize this deletions, I have
    accesslog configurated, I can see in the second one log these
    changes but the first one the deletions shows modifys

Regards, Buchan

Hello, I have upgrated openLDAP to 2.4.10, and I can t fix that situation Someone know what is the problem? or really is a bug?

Regards Migue

I 'm working with openLDAP 2.4.9.

...

I'm testing in a Lab to realize an implementation after that.

I make changes in master A, meanwhile master B is not working; after that master A stop. There are no masters working. I restart master A and master B manually, when I look for differences: master A is OK master B has the adds OK, but the deletions are not synchronized.

I'm going to upgrade to 2.4.10 meanwhile

Thanks.

Regards Migue

On Mon, 2008-07-07 at 11:30 -0300, Miguel Jinez wrote:

...

...

    Hi.
    I need help to fix a problem.
    I am running openLdap 2.4

Can you provide the exact version number?

...

...

    I have configurated 2 multimaster servers, which works fine,
    but I was thinking what happen if one of them die? When that
    master is restarted read the "logold" parameter in the other
    master and synchronize the changes, problem solved.
    But what happen if one master dies, meanwhile the other master
    performs changes in the Ldap tree (add, modify, delete) and
    that master dies too?

You would have no working master?

I assume you mean if changes are made on both sides while replication is not occurring. Except for conflicting changes (where the most recent change will win), all the changes should converge on all servers.

...

    I have test it and the deletes that I made in the second
    master are not synchronized on the first one,

I think there were some bugs fixed between 2.4.8 and 2.4.10 regarding replication of deletions. If you aren't running 2.4.10, you should upgrade and test again. If you still have problems, you should file an ITS.

...

     and I don t know how I can synchronize this deletions, I have
    accesslog configurated, I can see in the second one log these
    changes but the first one the deletions shows modifys

Regards, Buchan